sexta-feira, 11 de dezembro de 2020

Ethical reflections on a Canadian scandal: When will Academia take a stand against entrenched "traditions" that bind society to a tribalistic past ?



In light of the recent Canadian scandal (link provided above), it prompts reflection on several pertinent questions:
1 - In the wake of events unfolding in a purportedly first-world country, it raises a crucial question: what can we anticipate in terms of ethical standards in third-world countries?  
2 - The time has come for academia to boldly condemn the brutality inherent in competitive sports. When will the academic community summon the courage to take a stance against practices that compromise ethical principles?  
3 - A pertinent query arises regarding academics who derive pleasure from the violence inherent in sports: do they possess the ethical foundation necessary to continue thriving within the academic realm?

Reflecting on Noam Chomsky's call in 1967 for academia to to speak the truth and to expose lies, it becomes evident that, over half a century later, the imperative extends beyond mere veracity. Academia must not only persist in truth-telling but also take a stand against entrenched "traditions" that bind society to a tribalistic past.  

P.S. Enclosed below is an email sent almost three years ago, addressing a similar concern on this matter.

______________________________________________________________________
De: F. Pacheco Torgal
Enviado: 15 de Fevereiro de 2018 8:05
Assunto: Another relic of the XX century that academia does not need

Competitive sports are just a die-hard relic of the XX century but the most bizarre thing is that Universities fell into the temptation to please a rising sports market and as a consequence sports performance has even become a science worth university status.

Competitive sports are just something that comes from a past of survival, of competition to the death, of winners and losers, of us versus them. Of race improvement and eugenics. Of males fighting each other in order to be able to mate with as many females as possible to pass their "superior" genes. That´s a narrative that we do not need in the 21st century. Even Olympic games make no sense in the 21st century because the heroes (the role models) of this century ought to be those that help Humanity to solve their many and worrying problems, not those that spend thousands of hours training in or order to be the human that runs faster, jumps higher or that throws a heavy object to a longer distance. That´s nothing more than a meaningless and unsustainable waste of resources.

To make things even worse let´s not forget that for instance sports teams in the Universities in the US have a long record of scandals including forging the grades of thousands of students, match-fixing, you name it. The recent Nassar scandal is a very good example of how a university's reputation can be tainted by such connections. The simple fact that highly competitive sports are now more and more associated with the doping industry and the multimillion-rising match-fixing would be reason enough for universities to avoid such a dark area.

https://www.forbes.com/sites/roomykhan/2017/12/31/doping-in-sports-cheating-or-leveling-of-the-playing-field/#42ced36c75ec

If the work of the intellectuals is to transform the unthinkable into plausible it would be a great achievement if academia were able to convince society about how highly competitive sports keep us imprisoned to our tribal past thus preventing the advancement of Humanity towards the type 1 civilization that we need and hope to become.