sábado, 7 de dezembro de 2019

Highly cited researchers (HCRs) seem to be part of the problem

There are only 141 HCRs that have at least 100 confirmed reviews 

they are not into editorial activities also because there are only 18 HCRs who have at least 100 confirmed editorial records https://publons.com/researcher/?hcr=1&order_by=verified_editor_records

It seems that what they love to do is to publish, publish, publish and publish again because there are 227 HCRs who have at least 700 ISI indexed publications. 
Owen Petchey and Jeremy Fox defined them as“cheats” for co-authoring hundreds of papers without doing proportionate reviewing but I think that the accurate term is parasites. 

Also this not the best way to tackle the deluge publication which is mentioned in the paper below
"Scientific production is steadily growing, exhibiting 4% annual growth in publications…science has become stifled by a publication deluge destabilizing the balance between production and consumption....an increasing focus on production over consumption also means that researchers will spend...less time reading and digesting the literature"

Not to mention that since now "More than 40 per cent of global R&D is now performed by just 200 companies" https://sciencebusiness.net/news/governments-risk-losing-control-over-direction-technology-research-oecd-warns that means Academia has a special duty to ensure the publications generated by corporate researchers are helping science instead of helping to destroy it. On this issue see below the cases of research fraud by Theranos and Monsanto: 

“Highvaluation companies that publish little or nothing in the peerreviewed literature may still have patents related to their products… However, patents do not offer the same level of documentation as peerreviewed articles. For example, Theranos had over 100 patents, but....when a team of investigators used the Theranos technology to run 22 common lab tests versus the same tests run with other companies’ technologies, the problematic error rates became manifest...”  https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1111/eci.13072
https://www.spiegel.de/international/world/monsanto-papers-reveal-company-covered-up-cancer-concerns-a-1174233.html